Get Your Home Value →
Free Toquerville Home Valuation

What's my home
worth in Toquerville?

A real number from a local agent, not a Zestimate guess. Real Washington County MLS comps from Anderson Junction, Westfield, the Heights, Firelight, Trail Ridge, the downtown grid along Ash Creek, and every other Toquerville pocket. About 4 minutes to fill out. Free, no obligation, no signup wall.

Scott Buehler, dual-licensed REALTOR and mortgage lender serving Toquerville, Utah
Trailing 12 months
$599,000
Median Toquerville single-family sale price
The Utah problem

Why Zillow and Redfin miss in Toquerville specifically.

Utah is one of twelve non-disclosure states. When a home closes in Toquerville, the sale price is not filed with the Washington County recorder and not entered into any public record. Sellers can even pay a fee to keep the price off the MLS itself.

National automated valuation models pull from public sale records first. In a non-disclosure state, that input simply does not exist. The algorithm is left guessing from tax assessments, square footage, and outdated comps.

Toquerville compounds the problem. The MLS only counts 29 residential closings citywide over the trailing twelve months. That is a thin sample for any algorithm to learn from. Throw in the fact that a downtown character home on the Ash Creek grid, a half-acre Anderson Junction parcel near I-15, a Heights bench-view build, and a five-acre property east of town all trade on completely different curves, and the Zestimate on your phone is fighting an unwinnable fight.

Zillow's published Zestimate accuracy
Zillow's own data, nationwide medians. Off-market is what every Toquerville homeowner sees.
Homes actively listed
1.74%
Median error. The algorithm has the live list price to anchor to.
Off-market homes (your home)
7.20%
Median error nationwide. Non-disclosure states like Utah usually run higher.
What that means in Toquerville
$43,000 swing
on a $599,000 home at Zillow's own off-market error rate. In either direction. That is a real-money pricing mistake on either side.
Source: zillow.com/zestimate, accessed 5/14/2026.
The six things that actually matter

What drives Toquerville home values right now.

Toquerville is the fastest-moving market in Washington County (53-day average DOM, fastest of any city), but the price curve inside the city is wide. Here is what actually moves the number on a specific home.

Driver 01

Which sub-area you sit in

The single biggest swing factor in Toquerville. Anderson Junction near I-15 Exit 27 trades on commute access. The downtown grid along Ash Creek and Center Street trades on character and the original townsite feel. The Heights trades on bench-view elevation. Westfield (anchored by Almond Heights) and Firelight trade on subdivision finish levels. Trail Ridge / Cholla trades on view orientation. Same MLS, six different conversations.

Driver 02

Acreage and lot size

Toquerville lots run noticeably larger than Hurricane or La Verkin. Half-acre and one-acre parcels are common, the larger acreage runs east of town carry their own premium, and many lots have RV parking, outbuildings, gardens, or room for animals. For the Wasatch Front move-down family and the retiree buyer pricing this against St. George options, lot size is often the entire pitch.

Driver 03

View premiums

Pine Valley Mountain views from the bench above town, Zion peak sightlines from the Heights and Trail Ridge, and the red-rock cliff backdrop along the Ash Creek and La Verkin Creek corridors. Two identical floor plans can sell tens of thousands apart based on which way the great room faces. Bluff homes above the creek are their own premium tier.

Driver 04

Zion gateway and I-15 access

Toquerville sits 20 miles north of St. George, 30 miles south of Cedar City, and SR-17 is the direct corridor to Zion National Park. That positioning pulls Wasatch Front retirees, Zion-corridor second-home buyers, and St. George commuters who want acreage they can't get in Washington Fields. Homes near Anderson Junction with quick I-15 Exit 27 access price differently than properties tucked into the east-side acreage.

Driver 05

Short-term rental restrictions

Toquerville's nightly rental rules are more restrictive than Hurricane or Apple Valley. Most residential zones do not permit short-term rentals as a matter of right, and the city has specific overlay districts where they are conditionally allowed. That keeps the buyer pool primary-residence and retirement, not Airbnb-driven. If your home happens to be a permitted STR or sits in a conditional overlay, that is a real, marketable premium for the right buyer and the zoning needs to be confirmed in writing.

Driver 06

New construction supply

D.R. Horton and other production builders are active in Toquerville, and active inventory grew 115 percent year over year. Builder rate buydowns and finish upgrades directly compete with comparable resale pricing in the same area. If your home is a newer build or a recent resale in Westfield, Firelight, or one of the production subdivisions, that supply matters more to your value than the city-wide median does.

Toquerville price band

Most Toquerville homes trade between $475K and $950K.

Bluff homes above the creek, larger acreage parcels east of town, and view-driven Heights custom builds run well into the seven figures. Modular and manufactured homes on owned land sit below the band. Where your specific home sits inside this range depends on sub-area, view, lot size, condition, and the six drivers above.

Modular
$388K
median
Single Family
$599K
median
Toquerville city, trailing 12 months ending 5/1/2026. Source: Washington County MLS via FlexMLS.
What actually sold

Toquerville recent sold range, trailing 12 months.

Real numbers from real closings inside Toquerville city limits. Pulled from the Washington County MLS via FlexMLS on 5/14/2026, covering the trailing twelve months ending 5/1/2026.

Single Family
27 sold
$599,000
Median sale price
Average sale price $690,864
Days on market 53 days
Percent of list 98%
YoY closings +145% (11 to 27)
Modular / Manufactured
2 sold
$387,500
Median sale price
Average sale price $387,500
Days on market ~80 days
Percent of list 96%
YoY closings +200% (0 to 2)
Citywide residential
29 sold
$19.4M
Total sold volume
YoY volume +163%
Avg DOM (citywide) 53 days
Fastest in Wash. County
Under contract 39 (vs 20 active)

Source: Washington County MLS via FlexMLS, sold market analysis 5/1/2025 to 5/1/2026, pulled 5/14/2026. No condo or townhouse closings inside Toquerville city limits during the period. Brokered by Real Broker LLC. Mortgage services through Guild Mortgage, NMLS 1794818.

Hyperlocal Valuation

Most online estimates are off by 8 to 12 percent in this market.

The questionnaire takes about 4 minutes and combines real Washington County MLS data with on-the-ground knowledge of your specific Toquerville pocket. I read every submission personally, pull the comps myself, and send back a written pricing band, usually within one business day.

Free, no obligation, no marketing list. Just an honest number.

~4 minutes to fill out
Real MLS comps from your pocket
Written pricing band back within 1 business day
Free, no signup wall, no marketing list
Start the Questionnaire →

Or call Scott directly at (435) 357-4345

Questions, answered honestly

Toquerville home value FAQ.

Why does Zillow show a different number for my Toquerville home?

Utah is one of twelve non-disclosure states. Sale prices in Toquerville are not recorded in Washington County public records, and Utah property owners can pay a fee to remove their sale price from the MLS itself. Zillow and Redfin build their estimates from a much thinner dataset in Utah than they do in California or Arizona.

Zillow publishes a 7.20 percent median error rate for off-market homes nationwide, and non-disclosure states usually run higher. Toquerville compounds the problem with only 29 residential closings citywide over the trailing twelve months, which is a thin sample for any algorithm to learn from. On a $599,000 Toquerville home, that is a $43,000 swing in either direction. The Zestimate is a starting point, not a number to price a listing against.

How accurate is the Scott Buehler valuation?

The questionnaire feeds a real comparative market analysis. It combines current Washington County MLS sold data, active and pending comps inside your specific Toquerville pocket, condition and upgrade notes you provide, and on-the-ground context.

Over the trailing twelve months, the average Toquerville seller closed within 98 percent of original list price. That is what real pricing looks like when the number is built from comps, not an algorithm.

Do I have to list my home to get a valuation?

No. The valuation is free, no listing agreement, no obligation, no pressure. Plenty of Toquerville homeowners use it to plan a refinance, contest a Washington County property tax assessment, settle an estate, or just sanity check the Zestimate they keep seeing on their phone.

If you do decide to sell down the road, you already have a baseline number and you already know who I am. That works for both of us.

How long does the questionnaire take?

About 4 minutes. Address, basic specs, any recent upgrades, condition notes, and where you are in your timeline.

From there I pull the comps myself. Most people get a written pricing band back within one business day, faster if you flag it as time-sensitive.

Is there a cost?

No cost. No signup wall. No marketing list. The valuation is how I introduce myself to Toquerville homeowners, and it is genuinely free whether or not you ever decide to sell.

What is the median home price in Toquerville right now?

Across the trailing twelve months ending 5/1/2026, single-family homes inside Toquerville city limits sold at a median of $599,000 with an average of $690,864 across 27 closed sales. All residential property types combined (single-family plus modular and manufactured) totaled 29 closings at roughly $19.4 million in sold volume, with a median around $599,000. Sellers closed at 98 percent of original list price on average, about $14,474 below list.

Closings jumped 145 percent year over year and sold dollar volume rose 163 percent. Toquerville's 53-day average days on market is the fastest in Washington County, faster than St. George, Hurricane, Washington, Ivins, and Santa Clara. Source: Washington County MLS via FlexMLS.

Does my Toquerville neighborhood matter more than the city average?

Yes, more than almost any other factor. Toquerville is not one market. Anderson Junction at the north end near I-15 Exit 27 trades on commute access. The downtown grid along Ash Creek and Center Street trades on character and the original townsite feel. The Heights trades on Pine Valley Mountain and Zion sightlines. Westfield (anchored by Almond Heights) and Firelight trade on subdivision finish levels and newer construction. Trail Ridge / Cholla trades on view orientation. The acreage parcels east of town trade on land entirely.

A city-wide $599,000 median tells you nothing about a specific home on the bluff above the creek or a half-acre parcel near Anderson Junction. Your specific pocket is what the questionnaire focuses on.

Keep reading

More on selling and buying in Toquerville.

Scott Buehler, REALTOR and mortgage lender
Dual-licensed Authority
REALTOR & Lender
Ready when you are

Get a real number for your Toquerville home.

Start with the questionnaire, or call directly. The pricing band is honest, the comps are real, and there is zero pressure to do anything next.